Skip to content
Boyu's Blog

A Breakdown of the Zionist Consensus Among US Jewish Community: What Is Emerging Today.

Marking two years after the deadly assault of 7 October 2023, which deeply affected world Jewry unlike anything else following the founding of the state of Israel.

Among Jewish people the event proved profoundly disturbing. For the Israeli government, it was deeply humiliating. The entire Zionist project was founded on the belief that the Jewish state would ensure against things like this repeating.

A response seemed necessary. But the response Israel pursued – the widespread destruction of the Gaza Strip, the casualties of tens of thousands of civilians – constituted a specific policy. This particular approach complicated the perspective of many Jewish Americans understood the October 7th events that set it in motion, and currently challenges their remembrance of the day. How can someone mourn and commemorate a tragedy against your people while simultaneously devastation done to a different population in your name?

The Difficulty of Mourning

The challenge in grieving lies in the fact that there is no consensus about the significance of these events. In fact, for the American Jewish community, this two-year period have experienced the disintegration of a fifty-year agreement regarding Zionism.

The beginnings of pro-Israel unity within US Jewish communities dates back to an early twentieth-century publication written by a legal scholar who would later become supreme court justice Louis D. Brandeis titled “The Jewish Problem; Addressing the Challenge”. But the consensus truly solidified after the 1967 conflict that year. Before then, US Jewish communities contained a fragile but stable coexistence between groups which maintained a range of views concerning the necessity for a Jewish nation – pro-Israel advocates, non-Zionists and anti-Zionists.

Previous Developments

This parallel existence persisted through the 1950s and 60s, through surviving aspects of Jewish socialism, within the neutral American Jewish Committee, in the anti-Zionist American Council for Judaism and similar institutions. Regarding Chancellor Finkelstein, the head of the theological institution, Zionism was more spiritual instead of governmental, and he did not permit performance of the Israeli national anthem, the Israeli national anthem, at religious school events in those years. Nor were Zionism and pro-Israelism the main element for contemporary Orthodox communities prior to the six-day war. Alternative Jewish perspectives existed alongside.

But after Israel overcame neighboring countries in the six-day war that year, taking control of areas including the West Bank, Gaza, Golan Heights and East Jerusalem, the American Jewish connection with the country underwent significant transformation. Israel’s victory, combined with persistent concerns regarding repeated persecution, resulted in a growing belief in the country’s vital role to the Jewish people, and created pride in its resilience. Discourse regarding the remarkable quality of the outcome and the “liberation” of land provided the Zionist project a theological, almost redemptive, significance. In that triumphant era, considerable existing hesitation about Zionism disappeared. In the early 1970s, Commentary magazine editor Norman Podhoretz stated: “Everyone supports Zionism today.”

The Consensus and Its Boundaries

The pro-Israel agreement excluded strictly Orthodox communities – who generally maintained a Jewish state should only be established through traditional interpretation of the Messiah – but united Reform Judaism, Conservative, Modern Orthodox and nearly all secular Jews. The predominant version of the unified position, what became known as left-leaning Zionism, was founded on the idea regarding Israel as a democratic and liberal – albeit ethnocentric – country. Countless Jewish Americans viewed the control of Palestinian, Syria's and Egypt's territories after 1967 as provisional, thinking that a resolution would soon emerge that would maintain Jewish population majority within Israel's original borders and neighbor recognition of Israel.

Two generations of American Jews grew up with support for Israel a core part of their identity as Jews. The nation became a key component of Jewish education. Israeli national day evolved into a religious observance. Blue and white banners were displayed in many temples. Seasonal activities were permeated with Israeli songs and the study of modern Hebrew, with visitors from Israel and teaching American teenagers Israeli customs. Travel to Israel expanded and achieved record numbers through Birthright programs during that year, when a free trip to the country was provided to Jewish young adults. The nation influenced nearly every aspect of the American Jewish experience.

Shifting Landscape

Ironically, throughout these years after 1967, Jewish Americans became adept regarding denominational coexistence. Acceptance and dialogue between Jewish denominations increased.

Except when it came to the Israeli situation – that represented diversity ended. Individuals might align with a rightwing Zionist or a progressive supporter, however endorsement of the nation as a Jewish homeland was a given, and questioning that perspective categorized you beyond accepted boundaries – a non-conformist, as one publication termed it in writing in 2021.

Yet presently, during of the destruction in Gaza, food shortages, dead and orphaned children and anger about the rejection by numerous Jewish individuals who refuse to recognize their involvement, that consensus has collapsed. The moderate Zionist position {has lost|no longer

Written by

Amanda Estrada

Marco is an archaeologist and historian specializing in Roman antiquity, with over 15 years of experience in excavating and studying Pompeii's artifacts.

Boyu's Blog

Type to search articles.