🔗 Share this article

During a preview for the famed producer's upcoming Netflix series, viewers encounter a scene that feels almost nostalgic in its dedication to past days. Perched on several neutral-toned couches and formally clutching his knees, the executive discusses his aim to create a fresh boyband, twenty years subsequent to his initial TV talent show launched. "It represents a massive risk with this," he states, laden with drama. "Should this backfires, it will be: 'Simon Cowell has lost it.'" However, for those noting the shrinking ratings for his current programs understands, the probable reply from a large majority of today's 18- to 24-year-olds might actually be, "Simon who?"

The Challenge: Is it Possible for a Television Titan Adapt to a Changed Landscape?

This does not mean a current cohort of viewers cannot lured by his expertise. The question of whether the veteran executive can refresh a well-worn and long-standing model is less about current pop culture—fortunately, as hit-making has increasingly moved from television to apps including TikTok, which he admits he loathes—than his extremely time-tested ability to create compelling television and mold his persona to suit the era.

In the promotional campaign for the new show, the star has made an effort at showing remorse for how harsh he once was to contestants, apologizing in a major outlet for "being a dick," and explaining his eye-rolling performance as a judge to the monotony of audition days instead of what the public understood it as: the mining of laughs from confused individuals.

Repeated Rhetoric

Anyway, we have heard this before; Cowell has been offering such apologies after being prodded from reporters for a full 15 years at this point. He made them previously in the year 2011, in an interview at his temporary home in the Beverly Hills, a residence of polished surfaces and austere interiors. At that time, he spoke about his life from the viewpoint of a passive observer. It seemed, at the time, as if Cowell viewed his own personality as operating by market forces over which he had little say—warring impulses in which, of course, at times the less savory ones prevailed. Whatever the outcome, it was accompanied by a resigned acceptance and a "What can you do?"

This is a babyish evasion typical of those who, having done very well, feel under no pressure to explain themselves. Yet, one might retain a soft spot for Cowell, who merges US-style hustle with a uniquely and fascinatingly odd duck disposition that can really only be UK in origin. "I'm a weird person," he remarked during that period. "Indeed." His distinctive footwear, the idiosyncratic style of dress, the stiff body language; all of which, in the environment of Hollywood homogeneity, still seem somewhat likable. You only needed a look at the sparsely furnished mansion to ponder the challenges of that particular inner world. If he's a challenging person to collaborate with—and one imagines he is—when he speaks of his openness to all people in his employ, from the doorman onwards, to come to him with a winning proposal, one believes.

The New Show: An Older Simon and Modern Contestants

'The Next Act' will present an more mature, gentler incarnation of the judge, if because that's who he is now or because the market demands it, who knows—but this evolution is communicated in the show by the appearance of his longtime partner and glancing glimpses of their eleven-year-old son, Eric. While he will, probably, avoid all his old critical barbs, some may be more intrigued about the contestants. Specifically: what the gen Z or even gen Alpha boys trying out for Cowell believe their part in the new show to be.

"There was one time with a contestant," Cowell said, "who came rushing out on to the microphone and proceeded to shouted, 'I've got cancer!' Like it was a winning ticket. He was so thrilled that he had a tragic backstory."

During their prime, Cowell's reality shows were an early precursor to the now common idea of mining your life for content. The shift these days is that even if the young men auditioning on this new show make parallel strategic decisions, their online profiles alone guarantee they will have a more significant degree of control over their own personal brands than their equivalents of the mid-aughts. The more pressing issue is whether he can get a face that, similar to a well-known journalist's, seems in its default expression naturally to convey disbelief, to display something warmer and more congenial, as the era requires. This is the intrigue—the motivation to view the premiere.